registered alien

This  is  not  a  Victory  March

(blowback from a media consumer)

  • About me
  • Pictures
  • Japan Blog
  • Movie Reviews
  • Bad Poetry
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Education
  • Idioms
  • Religion
  • Books

capital  punishment  in  japan / capital  punishment  7

2/17/2014

0 コメント

 
Tuesday, February 18, 2014.

Readers in Council,
The Japan Times,
5-4, Shibaura 4-chome,
Minato-ku, Tokyo 108-0023  

For a long time one criticism of Japan has been the paucity of broad and deep public discussion of the use of capital punishment here, a lack of transparency in the process, and the treatment of convicts in detention in general.  Successive governments have trotted out statistics declaring overwhelming public support for execution.  But we know that the statistics are easily skewered depending on the wording of questions and the information provided to interviewees.  Statistics don’t mean nearly as much as the people who wield them think they do.  Too often it seems to have fallen to foreign contributors to Readers in Council to give these matters anything approaching critical public attention.  I don’t mean to assess the merits or demerits of the various pro and con arguments.  I just  mean an unfettered discussion of the matter as an important social issue largely ignored by Japanese and concealed by the government.

Now in “Provide details on hangings or halt them:  ex-lay judges” (Japan  Times, Tuesday, February 18, 2014) some former lay judges who even participated in death penalty cases lament “feeling guilty that they will sooner or later become ‘indirect murderers’ of fellow human beings.”  I was disappointed to read that because it doesn’t speak well of people’s understanding of society or the judicial sentencing issue.  Of course judges are partly responsible for killing fellow human beings!  Don’t they know it?  Capital punishment is judicial state murder.  Do they think the law exempts individual citizens from culpability?

None of us is innocent.  We like to think we are, but the point is that by supporting the polity through taxes and participation in society we are each of us accomplices in the actions the the polity.  I pay taxes in Japan.  The Japanese government judicially murders heinous criminals.  Therefore I know that I am an accomplice in murder (judicial murder by the state).  I am a participant in the society that executes people.  It always angers me when the paper quotes judges who hand down death sentences with the excruciatingly lame excuse that the sentence “can’t be helped.”  That is a common Japanese excuse for all manner of evil.

It is very disappointing that this elementary lesson, which people ought to learn in high school, is still not understood by adults who serve as lay judges.  The debate must proceed with the understanding that we are responsible for what we do as well as for what the government does on our behalf.




Published on Thursday, February 20, 2014 as “Some lay judges just don’t get it.”

0 コメント

    Author

    I am a permanent foreign resident in Japan.  I have no plan.  I don't know what I'm doing.

    Archives

    5 月 2017
    11 月 2016
    6 月 2016
    5 月 2016
    4 月 2016
    2 月 2016
    10 月 2015
    9 月 2015
    8 月 2015
    7 月 2015
    5 月 2015
    4 月 2015
    3 月 2015
    2 月 2015
    1 月 2015
    12 月 2014
    11 月 2014
    10 月 2014
    9 月 2014
    8 月 2014
    7 月 2014
    6 月 2014
    5 月 2014
    4 月 2014
    3 月 2014
    2 月 2014
    1 月 2014
    12 月 2013
    11 月 2013
    10 月 2013
    9 月 2013
    8 月 2013
    7 月 2013
    6 月 2013
    5 月 2013
    4 月 2013
    3 月 2013
    2 月 2013
    1 月 2013
    12 月 2012
    11 月 2012
    10 月 2012
    9 月 2012
    8 月 2012
    7 月 2012
    6 月 2012

    Categories

    すべて
    Abel Muzorewa
    Abomination By Any Other Name
    Abused Receptionist
    Admirable Humorous Production
    Adrian Peterson
    Alcohol Is A Drug 1
    A Less Ascetic Word For `monk`
    Alibi Firms
    Alien Card Not For Everyone`s Eyes
    A Little Red Blends Right In
    A Little Slack For Letter-writers
    Al-Qaida`s Goal Not Unreasonable
    American Empire Is Waging A `permanent War`
    An Expert Best Kept In Check
    Anne Of Green Gables
    Anonymous Urban Life
    Anti War Crowd
    A Persistent Voice For Equality
    Appearance Of Working Hard
    Asashoryu`s Mental Health
    Ashes To Ashes
    A Strong And Big-hearted People
    Atheism
    Atomic Bomb Apology
    Baby Cry Sumo
    Baby Sumo Competition Is A Crying Shamea3e5a2b4d9
    Banning Bicycles
    Ban This Intolerble Stock Phrase
    Bareheaded Putin Misses Chance
    Beatlemania
    Becky
    Behavior Warrants Terror Charge
    Beware The National Mythology
    Bicycle Bell For Emergencies
    Black Cats
    Blame Time Closing Fast
    Break Out The Steroids
    Bullying
    Bush Cut From Same Cloth
    Button Issue Identity
    Campaign Noise Maker
    Capital Punishment 1
    Capital Punishment 2
    Capital Punishment 3
    Capital Punishment 4
    Capital Punishment 5
    Capital Punishment 6
    Capital Punishment 7
    Capital Punishment In Japan
    Capture Wont Make Us Safereb288c7fd6
    Caution: Slower-moving Era Ahead
    Challenge For The Naturalized
    Challenging An American Icon
    Charlie Sheen
    Child Abduciton Agreement
    Child Abduction 1
    Child Abduction 2
    Child Abduction 3
    Child Abduction 4
    Child Abuse Culture
    China Should Unite With Taiwan
    Chiune Sugihara
    Christmas Day Earthquake And Tsunami
    Christopher Savoie 1
    Christopher Savoie 2
    Circumcision 1
    Circumcision 10
    Circumcision 2
    Circumcision 3
    Circumcision 4
    Circumcision 5
    Circumcision 6
    Circumcision 7
    Circumcision 8
    Circumcision 9
    Coach Is Gone And Good Riddance
    Columnist Was Misunderstood
    Convenient Mental Illness Hedge
    Cool Biz
    Coolest Man Alive 1
    Coolest Man Alive - 2
    Cool Japan
    Course Doesn`t Make The Grade
    Crime And Punishment
    Criminalize Bullying To Emphasize Its Illegality
    Critique Of Culinary Culture
    Culture Shift To Make Cycling Safer
    Cursive Writing
    Dangerous Japanese Nationalism
    Daylight Saving Doubts
    Daylight Saving Time
    Daylight Saving Time In Japan
    Death Penalty Foes Have It Wrong
    Death Penalty Pros And Cons
    Death Pictures
    Debito Stands Out
    Delhi Ignores Quake Peril
    Desert Island Reading
    Donald Sterling 1
    Donald Sterling 2
    Don`t Blame U.N. For Iraq`s Plight
    Do The Right Thing With Fujimorri
    Drinking Culture
    Drivel From Populist Politicians
    Dumb Remarks Deserve Pity
    Elderly Bad Behavior
    English Gets Strength From Bottom-up Nature
    Entertaining Contrary Ideas
    Environment 1
    Equality Of Housing Insulation
    Escalator Manners
    Eternal Tweaking Of Tokyo Station
    Ethics And Morality Differ
    Evacuation Revelations Shocking
    Even Nazis Had Their Reasons
    Exodus: Gods And Kings
    Expatriate Voting Rights In Canada
    Expect Powering Up To Be Harder
    Expendable Foreign Employees
    Expressions To Avoid Discomfort
    False Promise Of More Intelligence
    Family Values And The Bible
    Family Values Not Carved In Stone
    Fantasy Faith In Schools
    Fear And Loathing Of Foreign Votes
    Feminine Vehicles
    Fingerprinting Foreigners
    Fly-jin
    Fond Animal Stories
    Food Safety Laws
    For Africa`s Sake Stop Money Aid
    Foregiveness
    Foreigner Crime Rate
    Foreign Suffrage 1
    Foreign Suffrage 2
    Foreign Suffrage 3
    Foreign Vote In Japan
    Forgiving Animals
    Freedom In Urbam Anonymity
    Freedom To Dislike Anything
    Freedom To Feel
    Frivolous Lists About Nothing
    Fueling The Polygraph Test
    Gaijin Pride
    Galileo Invited His Persecution
    Gay Outing
    Geologic Time
    George Mcgovern
    Global Warming
    Global Warming Model Lives
    Global Warming Trend Beyond Us
    God-loving Christians With Guns
    Good Vs. Bad Religion
    Good Writing Wrong Conclusions
    Governing Versus Ruling 1
    Governing Versus Ruling 2
    Govt Scaremongering Over Population Decline
    `Greatest Evil` Not Apparent
    Great Need For Christian Witness
    Grief Not The Same As Mourning
    Guelph Breast Festival
    Guelph City Hall Has Pleasant Appearance
    Guelph Mercury - End Print Edition
    Guelph Resident Changed By Staying In Japan After 3/11 Disaster
    Guilt Lasts Forever
    Guilt Makes Us Human
    Hague Convention 1
    Hague Convention 2
    Hague Convention 3
    Hague Convention 4
    Hague Convention 5
    Hague Convention 6
    Hague Convention 7
    Hague Convention In Japan
    Haruko Arimura Pandora`s Box
    Haven`t Former Convicts Paid Debt To Society?
    Holocaust Victims
    Homogenous Japan 1
    Homogenous Japan 2
    Hopeful Sign On A Wall In Beijing
    Hosokawa Out Of Step
    Human Skin Color
    Ian Thorpe Gay
    Illegal Dumping In Guelph
    Imperial Primogeniture
    Impossible To Live Without Risks
    India / China Sexual Conservatism
    Indian Values
    Infantile Use Of `racism` Label
    Information Lacking
    Intelligent Presidential Candidates 1
    Intelligent Presidential Candidates 2
    Ishihara
    It`s Worth The Effort To Keep The Dam
    Iwao Hakamada
    Japan - Baby Cry Sumo
    Japan Building Scandals
    Japanese And Logic
    Japanese Child Custody
    Japanese Demographic Crisis
    Japanese Dentistry
    Japanese Elderly 1
    Japanese Elderly 2
    Japanese Emperor's Role
    Japanese Feelings Often A Decoy
    Japanese 'hafu' Talents
    Japanese Head Of State
    Japanese Imperial Ambitions In Asia
    Japanese-insincere-greetings
    Japanese Male Sex Aversion
    Japanese Movement
    Japanese `omotenashi` Hospitality
    Japanese Parable
    Japanese Population Fix
    Japanese Seem Easy To Brainwash
    Japanese Social Recluses
    Japanese Street Noise
    Japanese Terrorism 1
    Japanese Terrorism 2
    Japanese Tourism
    Japanese University Entrance Exams
    Japan Immigration
    Japan's Aging Population
    Japans Censorship Culture7a4048dd52
    Japan Secrecy Bill And Terrorism
    Japan's Low Birth Rate
    Japan's Population Problem
    Japan Standardized English Signs
    Japan`s War Of Aggression
    Jean Jackson
    Jenkins Being `kidnapped` By Koizumi Administration
    Jesus` Divinity Already Decided
    Jun Hasegawa
    Justice System Works
    Just More Celebrity Make-believe
    Kazuyoshi Miura
    Keep The Wrecking Ball At Bay
    Kill With Regret And Humility
    Kuril Island Sovereignty 1
    Kuril Island Sovereignty 2
    Lack Of Forgiveness
    Laissez-faire Policy Beats Censorship
    Leslie Van Houten
    Letter From An Alternate Universe
    Let The Tobacco Tax Drift Higher
    Lies Can`t Foster Genuine Patriotism
    Life Is A Story
    Long War Against Terrorism 1
    Long War Against Terrorism 2
    Low Intelligence High Crime
    Loyal Dog Hachiko
    Magic Johnson
    Making Best Use Of The `military`
    Male Circumcision A Form Of Child Abuse
    Mandatory Sports Demoralizing 1
    Mandatory Sports Demoralizing 2
    Many Confused Over Xmas/Christmas
    Maple Leaf Flag
    Mark Mcgwire
    Masako Owada
    Mascots
    Maternity Badges
    Mental Lapse On The Bullet Trains
    Michael Slager
    Mideast Article Has It Wrong
    Minami Minegishi
    Minding Your `X` At Christmas
    Misadventures Of Young Jets
    Misplaced Excitement Of The G-8
    Mistaken Complacenct In Dangerous Times
    Misunderstanding Insulation
    Mixed Messages About Manners
    Modern Life Needs N-option
    Moving Past The Debate About Race
    Municipal Cash Grab Resented
    Muslim Slur
    Mutsuhiro Takeuchi
    Negligent Baby Doctor
    Nelson Mandela Hero And Icon
    New Dark Age
    No Country For Traditional Values
    No Dregree In Common Sense
    No Free Lunch In Education
    North Korea Foolish Childish
    North Pole Santa Claus
    No Substitute For Japanese Rice
    Not 1 Innocent Among Us
    Nova English School
    Obama In Hiroshima
    Obey The Rules
    Of Crime And Foreigners
    Okunishi Case Shameful For Japan`s Judiciary
    Old Guelph Impressions
    Old News Shouldn`t Be Treated As A Novelty
    Olympics Demoralizing
    Olympics Versus World Championships
    Olympic Volunteer Classes
    Olympic Wrestling 1
    Olympic Wrestling 2
    Opportunity To Decentralize Tokyo
    Organ Donation
    Our Self-image Needs Improvement
    Over-analyzing British Riots
    Overlooked Aspects Of Beauty
    Overtime Work
    Palestine 1
    Palestine 2
    Passenger Pigeon
    Patriotic Dissent
    Personhood Is An Achievement
    Pet Pig
    Petrie Building Guelph Ontario
    Pine Beetles Of Western Canada
    Pledge Of Allegiance Problematic
    Police Pose More Danger To Public Than Criminals
    Polish Pedophile
    Polite Service Missed Overseas
    Political Noisemaker Not Innocent
    Political Noise Makers
    Politicians Should Show Reason
    Polygraph Test
    Population Decline
    Pregnant Schoolgirls Also Have Right To Education
    Preparing For The 2020 Olympics
    Priest Sex Abuse
    Prime Minister Aso
    Princess` Guardians Need Greater Public Scrutiny
    Privacy
    Privacy Of Ian Thorpe
    Public Drunkenness
    `public` Includes Foreigners
    Public Opinion In Political Life
    Public Servants
    Queen Versus Governor General
    Real Enemy Has Not Been Israel
    Regime Change
    Religion And Happiness
    Remember War Criminals
    Resolve Based On Nonsense
    Responsibility To Serve All Citizens
    Revel In Being A Misfit
    Revolution Was Good For Cuba
    Ridding The World Of Dictators
    Rob Ford
    Robocup 2010
    Rola
    Saaya Suzuki Murder
    Safe Life For Celibate Homebodies
    Salary Versus Wage
    Santa Claus 1
    Santa Claus 2
    Santa Claus 3
    Santa Claus 4
    Santa Claus 5
    Santa Claus 6
    Santa Claus 7
    School Vs. Education
    Science And Religion
    Sex Slave Row
    Shark Tale
    Short And To The Point
    Sloppy Use Of Language Complicates Issues
    Smokers Are Hazardous
    Social Competition Or Pathology?
    Social Engineering
    Social Health Insurance
    Someone Should Investigate Activities Of The Monster
    So Much Pain For So Little Gain
    South Carolina Police Shooting
    Spring May Be As Good As It Gets
    Stalling On Foreign Vote Just Putting Off Inevitable
    Standardized English For Road Signs
    Stands With A Fist
    Steroids
    Strange Use Of An English Idiom
    Students Neglect Physical Exercise
    Subject - Verb Agreement
    Suicide Intervention
    Sumo Bullying Death
    Sumo Child Abuse Crime - 1
    Sumo Child Abuse Crime - 2
    Sumo Child Abuse Crime 3
    Supermodel Beauty
    Symbolic Cleanliness Vs. Hygiene
    Taiwan U.N. Membership
    Takako Doi
    Takarazuka Revue
    Target Closure In Canada
    Teacher Assault
    Ted Rall
    Teen Suicide
    Territory Scavengers
    The Capital Punishment Debate
    The Case For Discrimination
    The Chance To Remake One`s Life
    The Great Earthquake And God
    The Heat Of Anti-Christian Passion
    The Japanese And Their Feelings
    The Myth Of An Aesthetic Sense
    This Is Not A Victory March
    Tokkyo Election Nuclear Focus
    Tokyo 2020 Summer Olympics
    Tokyo Dodged The Olympic Bullet
    Tokyo Execution Chamber 1
    Tokyo Execution Chamber 2
    Tokyo Governor Shintaro Ishihara
    Tokyo Olympic Troubles
    Tokyo Shark Carcass
    Tokyo Station
    Too Expensive To Raise Kids
    Too Focused On Money
    Too Late To Turn Back Now
    Toru Hashimoto Sex Slave
    Toru Hashimoto's Longevity
    Toru Hashimoto`s Tush
    Toru Hashimoto - Yakuza And Adultery
    To Speak Badly And Still Connect
    Treat Bullying As A Crime
    Troubleshooter`s Advisors Ill-qualified But So What?
    True Religion
    Ufos Definitely Exist
    Ugly Fashion
    Ugly Underside Of Victory
    U.N. Dictatorship Of Fools In Suits
    Unexplained Supernatural Phenomena - 1
    Unexplained Supernatural Phenomena - 2
    Unforgiveable Crimes
    University Students Start Job Hunt
    Unloved And Unwanted
    Unprofessional English Language Teachers
    Unrequitted Love For Pet Owners
    Unshown `Unbound` Unwelcome
    Useful Expressions For U.S. Visits
    Useless Engineering Achievement
    Vague Language Plagues Debate
    Vagueness Hinders Communication
    Vagueness In Communication
    Vietnam War A Crime
    Visits To Guelph Remind Of The City`s Greatness
    Walking Drug Addicts Among Us
    Walter Lamer Scott
    War Not Worth Dying For
    Western Man
    What Do We Owe The State?
    What Passes For Attractiveness
    What Sport?
    When Vagueness Is Expected
    Who Disgraces Japan?
    Who Is To Blame For Bombing Hiroshima?
    Who Paid For Those Medical Appointments?
    Who Won World War II ?
    Why I Like Japan
    Why The Opposition To An Empress?
    Willpower To Prosecute Bullies
    Windfall From Collapsing Buildings
    Winnie The Pooh
    With A Fiscal Stimulus For All
    Worldview With Shaky Foundation
    Worst Country In The World
    WW1 Centenary
    Xenophobic Drivel
    Zero Trust In Japanese Government

    RSS フィード

Proudly powered by Weebly
✕